Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Humanities Research: Sources and Strategies: Critical reception

What is "Critical Reception"?

The term "critical reception," or "reception history," refers to:

  • How a creative work (book, film, music, etc.) has been "received" -- that is, how audiences have reacted to it over time.
  • How a historical figure or event has been viewed over time.

This kind of research is done on:

  • Literary figures, artists
  • Historical figures and events

It's done in order to:

  • Trace various views of, and critical approaches to, the person or event over time
  • When editing an early document: need to research critical views of it
  • Graduate programs often specialize in a specific critical approach

Tips for Critcal Reception research

CURRENT SCHOLARLY REVIEWS:

  • Places the work (book, film, dance performance) into a context
  • How  it fits with previous scholarship  
  • How it is different, what does it contribute  
  • What it is lacking, gets wrong

Review essays:

  • Articles that review multiple works  
  • Give an overview of recent scholarship on a topic

 

HISTORICAL / EARLY REVIEWS:

  • May or may not be scholarly
  • Can help trace how an idea/book/film was understood or received over time: something that today is considered an important work might not have been when it first appeared. Can also help a researcher trace the arc of an artist's or scholar's work, compare early works with later ones
  • Or the opposite, can help you understand the critics who examined the work

 

COMPILATIONS OF CURRENT AND HISTORICAL REVIEWS / CRITICISM:

  • Gale Literature Criticism series, now part of the Literature Resource Center database (see "Resources" below): include excerpts or entire early reviews
  • The Johns Hopkins Guide to Literary Theory and Criticism
  • Encyclopedias devoted to individual critical approaches, e.g. Encyclopedia of Feminist Criticism, Encyclopedia of Postcolonial Thought, etc
  • Bibliographies on an individual person or critical biographies (part biography, part critical study)

 

FINDING REVIEWS:

  • Search library catalogs for collections of reviews (an example: The Romantics Reviewed: Contemporary Reviews of British Romantic Writers). Add to your search terms "Reviews" or  "Book reviews."
  • Use search terms to convey a critical approach, e.g. Whitman AND masculinities
  • Bibliographies may include reviews. Add to your search terms "Bibliography."
  • Some library catalogs link to reviews, or allow you to limit your search to reviews.

Databases and reviews:

  • JSTOR (journals included are retrospective to first volumes published)
  • ProQuest Historical Newspapers
  • Many databases let you limit your search to reviews
  • Web of Science to track responses to seminal articles, books via "Cited Reference" searching
  • Subject-specific databases for art, music, dance, theater include reviews of performances, exhibitions

Citation indexes:

  • Web of Science (database) to track repsonses to seminal articles, books

 

CRITICAL APPROACHES:

The following may make useful search terms:

  • Archetypal
  • Postcolonial
  • Postmodernism
  • Multiculturalism
  • Deconstructivist
  • Feminist
  • Marxist
  • Socialist
  • Gender and masculinities
  • New criticism (work viewed in isolation)
  • New historicism (work viewed within historical context)
  • Ecocriticism
  • Structuralism
  • Psychoanalytic
  • Reader response (Derrida, Levi-Strauss, Heidigger, Freud, Bakhtin)
  • Allegorical
  • Literal
  • Historical
  • Textual
  • Form
  • Tradition
  • Oral
  • Sociological
  • Source
  • Redaction
  • Genre
  • Rhetorical
  • Narrative
  • Canonical
  • Myth
  • Practical

 

Critical Reception: Resources

Mindmap: Reference Resources

Mindmap: Sources of a creative work

Mindmap: Useful Keywords for searching library catalogs

Mindmap: Humanities Literature: How it's Published

 

Databases:

  • JSTOR
  • ProQuest Historical Newspapers
  • Times of London (on both our "Find a Journal" and "Find a Database" pages)
  • America: History and Life
  • Historical Abstracts
  • Annual Bibliography of English Language and Literature (ABELL)
  • Web of Science (citation indexing)

 

Literary criticism:

Gale's Literature Criticism series, now part of the LIterature Resource Center database, includes the following subsets:

  • Contemporary Literary Criticism (CLC)
  • Twentieth-Century Literary Criticism (TCLC)
  • Nineteenth-Century Literature Criticism
  • Literature Criticism 1400-1800
  • Hispanic Literature Criticism
  • Classical and medieval literature criticism (CMLC)
  • Short Story Criticism
  • Poetry Criticism
  • Drama Criticism

The Johns Hopkins Guide to Literary Theory and Criticism

Music:

Critical Reception: Should I do a Broad or Narrow Search?

Much critical literature focuses on a single work (for example, a book review) or on the works of a specific person (for example, their early or late works, or a theme in their works). You'll want to narrow your search accordingly.

Compilations of critical literature tend to be organized around a particular critical approach (feminist, etc.), genre (plays, etc.) or subject area, often limited to a geographical region or time period (twentieth-century English literature). Use keywords of this type in your search.

Need help? Chat with us